The Campaign for Greater Buffalo History, Architecture & Culture won a key decision by the New York Supreme Court Appellate Division for the Fourth Department today that reverses a lower court ruling that would have allowed the emergency demolition of the landmark Great Northern grain elevator. The appeals court agreed with the Campaign that the lower court the erred in refusing to permit The Campaign "to introduce certain proposed expert testimony and other evidence at the fact-finding hearing." Download Great Northern Decision

New York State Supreme Court Justice Emilio Colaiacovo in January lifted a temporary restraining order and allowing demolition to proceed. The Campaign appealed that decision, won a preliminary injunction, and argued the case before the appeals court earlier this month. The appeals court voted unanimously to reverse the lower court order, reinstated the restraining order, and remitted it back to State Supreme Court in Erie County for a hearing to include expert testimony and evidence from the Campaign.

"This is a huge victory for The Campaign, for the preservation movement, and anyone who cares about Buffalo's heritage and our waterfront," said Campaign Executive Tim Tielman. "We are confident that, once all the evidence is heard, it will be clear that the decision to demolish the Great Northern was rushed and not rational based on reasonably available facts."

The  history and significance of the Great Northern, and options to save and restore it will be discussed at a public meeting The Campaign is sponsoring on Saturday April 30 at noon at the Central Library Auditorium (a flier is attached below)

The Campaign sued the City of Buffalo to block the emergency demolition in December in State Supreme Court. The elevator sustained damage to its brick cladding during a windstorm on December 11. On December 17 the city issued an emergency demolition order. The Campaign contends that the building is structurally sound, that demolition is unnecessary, and that owner ADM should be required to repair and maintain the building, which they have not done during its ownership dating to 1993. The Great Northern has been a designated Buffalo landmark since 1990. Numerous parties have offered to buy and restore the waterfront giant, but thus far ADM refuses to sell.

The Great Northern has been embedded in the local landscape for 125 years. The Campaign for Greater Buffalo is fighting to keep it standing for another 125. Nancy J. Parisi photo.

By Paul McDonnell. Originally published in The Buffalo News April 5, 2022

The Great Northern grain elevator, the first and last of its kind, is still standing. It has just passed two significant anniversaries. February marked the 125th anniversary of the beginning of construction. More infamously, March 27 marked the 100th day since Buffalo’s Commissioner for Permits and Inspection Services issued an emergency demolition order to destroy the iconic Buffalo landmark, fearful of an imminent “collapse” because a section of brick cladding on the building’s north side had fallen on December 11.

The Great Northern won’t be collapsing anytime soon. Independent, informed, and licensed engineers and architects would tell you that.

Here’s why: The innovative steel frame of Max Toltz, Chief Engineer of the Great Northern Railway—the first railroad to cross the Continental Divide through the Cascade Mountains. Giant steel cylindrical grain bins are riveted together and to the frame to create a single solid mass of steel anchored to bedrock.

A schematic model (left) and a measured drawing (highlights added) show the robustness of the steel frame and cylindrical bins introduced to grain elevators by engineer Max Toltz. The measured drawing also shows, in black, the brick cladding (over two feet thick in some sections)with its own foundation anchored to bedrock.

Those thousands of tons of steel had to be isolated from the brick envelope, allowing them to expand and contract—to “breathe”— independently. Toltz’s solution was ingenious. The brick wall, several feet thick with its own foundation, merely keeps the weather out and bins shaded. Everything else is supported by the steel frame. From the ground, it looks like the roof rests on the walls, just as at your house. It doesn’t. The cupola doesn’t touch the brick walls, either. On the inside, the last 20 feet of either end of the cupola is hung—cantilevered—so no steel touches brick.

An elevator built by the New York Central Railroad in 1877 on landfill in the Hudson River off Manhattan had wooden framing and square wooden bins, but its foundation and brick walls were applied to the Great Northern 20 years later.

The form of the Great Northern was, and is, tried and true. Another railroad had established that 20 years earlier, with a wood-framed, wooden-binned behemoth in New York Harbor. Its brick walls were of the classic pier-and-panel design that could be seen on medieval churches and storehouses. The trick was to replace the wood with stronger, non-combustible steel, without the steel heaving against the brick enclosure. Toltz did that historically well.

The design of the Great Northern is robust and time-tested. Lack of proper maintenance is the problem. For example, lead flashing that capped the walls was allowed to deteriorate and go missing entirely. This resulted in unchecked water infiltration for decades, with bushes growing out of the north wall where it failed in December.

The Great Northern should have been fixed long ago, the owner held to account and directed by a city agency that knew what it was doing and acted in good faith. The Campaign for Greater Buffalo’s is fighting the emergency demolition order, and that is its argument. An appeals court in Rochester will decide beginning April 6th whether that argument has merit and whether the Great Northern ought to reign another 125 years as the Waterfront Queen of the Queen City.

Photgraphs dating to the 1980s show missing flashing above the north wall. By 2018 bushes were growing on top of the wall and bricks had fallen from the top of the wall. The December 11 collapse was at the same spot.